“Don’t be one, get one!”

I am back on my vaccine rant.  I wrote about it previously, with regards to the flu shot. I saw a video I thought was relevant.  I have also seen a few cases that are relevant.

I am on peds emerg, as you have probably noticed and well, I see a lot of sick kids.  And kids get sick.  No matter what you do.  Such is life.

But, I saw a 25 day old  baby who was very, very sick with the flu.  His Mom and two older siblings were sick earlier in the week and gave it to him.  Now, his life was at risk.  Maybe they would have gotten the flu anyway, but maybe if they had all been vaccinated, they would have protected their youngest sibling.

Rick Mercer, a delightful Newfoundlander who talks on all sorts of subjects did one of his “rant with Rick” features about flu shots.

Don’t be one, get one!

I also had a small battle with some parents who refuse to vaccinate their children (that is one’s own call). The concern was that they kid had cut his head open on a rusty nail and I suggested the tetanus vaccine.  They refused.  I reviewed the risks of tetanus.  I didn’t realize that they were against vaccines, I just thought he was due for one.  They started ranting at me about autism and stem cells.  I presented the evidence, but they made their own decisions.  That is a right we have.   I just informed them of what to watch for, reviewed risks and benefits and took some deep breaths.

I get it.  We all need to be educated in our own ways.  We all have our own ethical-moral decisions to make.

But, when I see little babies who may have whooping cough, a preventable illness, or people spreading the flu like wildfire, I can’t help but question it.

There is no evidence for the whole autism thing.  Heresay, some experiences, but no scientific evidence.  The one study that suggested it was a sham. Autism runs in families, it is a different way of thinking, not something that kills children.   Often, when you see children with autism, you may notice that the parents have a few traits.  Not always, but sometimes.  I have seen fabulous healthy people who happen to have autism do all kinds of fantastic things in life.

I can’t fix what has happened to families.  I don’t know why your kids were perfect and suddenly changed.

I do know the risks of dying from those diseases are higher than the risks of autism.

And I do know vaccine formulations have been changed to avoid thimerosol, the preservative everyone is scared of, where possible.

And I know people worry about the stem cell lines used in production of the vaccines.  That is a moral issue and I can’t really judge on that.  But I do caution people to think long and hard about the decision.

I am sure you recall Penn and Teller.  They also do a very entertaining, but educational feature on vaccines.  I have it included here, but I will warn that there is some VERY strong language at the end of the video, so please don’t watch it if you are sensitive to this or have others around (the first time I saw it was on a peds ward nursing station looking for presentation material… oops).

The moral of the story again is that vaccines save lives more than they take them.  And I feel very strongly about them.  I also understand others feel strongly the other way.  That is their opinion, just like I have mine.  I just wish it wouldn’t have such an impact on others.

I promise I will give this rant up for a little while now.

5 thoughts on ““Don’t be one, get one!”

  1. I stand with you on your soapbox. Had my flu shot and tdap. Better safe than sorry. I also respect the right to avoid on moral grounds. Just don’t feel that way personally.

    • I am glad you joined me on my soapbox!
      I agree, there is reason to refuse it on moral grounds. I also think people need to be educated about why it is recommended and the actual methods of production before making that decision.

  2. I am not anti vaccination – my kids have had all of theirs. However I do wonder (without any expertise or evidence, just my own thoughts on this) how logical it is to inject 4 or 5 different vaccines into a tiny body in one go. I think my babies had something like 6 different vaccines in 2 jabs at the same time age 8 weeks. How much their little bodies had to fight against them! Surely it is better to give them a few weeks apart, giving the body time to build up full defences against each one one at a time.
    When I mentioned this to the nurse I was informed I was a cruel mother, wanting to inflict 6 different injections on my child. But if it meant their bodies defences were stronger over all, is it really that cruel?
    With the MMR (measles mumps rubella) jab here in the UK which kicked off the autism fears here, I did go for 3 separate jabs. I had to pay privately to have it done. But the GP I saw said that doing it that way meant they only had each jab once, the body having time to fully adapt to each one, and therefore didn’t need the booster in a year or so. It made sense to me.

    • There is some good argument for spacing out the vaccines in some cases. And definitely nothing wrong with doing it except the extra jabs.
      The reasoning behind combining them is mainly the whole avoiding extra pokes. And technically the immune system can handle it, they have done research into it, but it does seem like a lot.
      I am glad you stood by your views for your children. And that they were vaccinated. And you weren’t cruel at all!
      Thanks for sharing your story!

  3. Pingback: My flu shot soapbox | At least we made it this far...

Please, share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s